Finding the best stays in Nantucket…
Scoring hotels on guest experience, location, and trust — the risks a star rating hides.
Finding the best stays in Nantucket…
Scoring hotels on guest experience, location, and trust — the risks a star rating hides.
46 hotels rated on the risks stars hide — cleanliness, noise, location, and whether the price is fair for what you get. Our top pick: Brass Lantern Inn.
32 scored · Highest Peace of Mind score first. Unscored stays appear last.
Looking for a specific hotel? Search it below — we'll score any property live, even if it's not in our ranked set.
Brass Lantern Inn
Peace of Mind83 / 100Few red flags — 4.9★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 368 reviews, 4-star, 8 amenities
4★ class · 4.9 guest rating · 368 reviews · 5 km from Center
Union Street Inn
Peace of Mind81 / 100Few red flags — 5.0★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 114 reviews, 5-star, 8 amenities
5★ class · 5.0 guest rating · 114 reviews · 5 km from Center
The Nantucket Hotel & Resort
Peace of Mind78 / 100Few red flags — 4.8★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 347 reviews, 4-star, 16 amenities
4★ class · 4.8 guest rating · 347 reviews · 5 km from Center
76 Main Ink Press Hotel
Peace of Mind76 / 100Few red flags — 4.8★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 112 reviews, 3-star, 6 amenities
3★ class · 4.8 guest rating · 112 reviews · 5 km from Center
21 Broad Hotel
Peace of Mind76 / 100Few red flags — 4.8★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 112 reviews, 4-star, 6 amenities
4★ class · 4.8 guest rating · 112 reviews · 5 km from Center
The Brant
Peace of Mind74 / 100Some red flags — 4.9★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 181 reviews, 3-star, 0 amenities
3★ class · 4.9 guest rating · 181 reviews · 5 km from Center

The Barnacle Inn
Peace of Mind74 / 100Some red flags — 4.9★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 73 reviews, 2-star, 6 amenities
2★ class · 4.9 guest rating · 73 reviews · 5 km from Center
Seven Sea Street Inn
Peace of Mind73 / 100Some red flags — 4.7★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 105 reviews, 4-star, 2 amenities
4★ class · 4.7 guest rating · 105 reviews · 5 km from Center
White Elephant Nantucket
Peace of Mind72 / 100Some red flags — 4.6★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 361 reviews, 4-star, 7 amenities
4★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 361 reviews · 5 km from Center
Carlisle House Inn
Peace of Mind72 / 100Some red flags — 4.7★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 146 reviews, 3-star, 5 amenities
3★ class · 4.7 guest rating · 146 reviews · 5 km from Center

The Chestnut House
Peace of Mind71 / 100Some red flags — 4.9★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 41 reviews, 3-star, 1 amenities
3★ class · 4.9 guest rating · 41 reviews · 5 km from Center
The Cottages at Nantucket Boat Basin
Peace of Mind71 / 100Some red flags — 4.7★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 47 reviews, 3-star, 13 amenities
3★ class · 4.7 guest rating · 47 reviews · 5 km from Center

Ships Inn
Peace of Mind69 / 100Some red flags — 4.6★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 52 reviews, 3-star, 0 amenities
3★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 52 reviews · 5 km from Center

Greydon House
Peace of Mind69 / 100Some red flags — 4.5★ guest rating; sleep 31% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 124 reviews, 4-star, 2 amenities
4★ class · 4.5 guest rating · 124 reviews · 5 km from Center

Anchor Inn
Peace of Mind68 / 100Some red flags — 4.6★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 65 reviews, 3-star, 5 amenities
3★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 65 reviews · 5 km from Center
The Wauwinet
Peace of Mind67 / 100Some red flags — 4.7★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 3.2★ location/transit/airport access; 10 km from the city centre
5★ class · 4.7 guest rating · 200 reviews · 10 km from Center
Jared Coffin House
Peace of Mind67 / 100Some red flags — 4.4★ guest rating; bathroom 42% negative, property 24% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 184 reviews, 5-star, 5 amenities
5★ class · 4.4 guest rating · 184 reviews · 5 km from Center
Regatta Inn by Nantucket Resort Collection
Peace of Mind67 / 100Some red flags — 4.8★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 52 reviews, unrated-class, 4 amenities
4.8 guest rating · 52 reviews · 5 km from Center
Periwinkle Inn
Peace of Mind67 / 100Some red flags — 4.7★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 30 reviews, unrated-class, 4 amenities
4.7 guest rating · 30 reviews · 5 km from Center

Martin House Inn
Peace of Mind67 / 100Some red flags — 4.6★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 60 reviews, 4-star, 5 amenities
4★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 60 reviews · 5 km from Center
The Beachside Hotel
Peace of Mind66 / 100Some red flags — 4.4★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 3.8★ location/transit/airport access
4★ class · 4.4 guest rating · 376 reviews · 5 km from Center
Life House Nantucket
Peace of Mind66 / 100Some red flags — 4.5★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 131 reviews, 4-star, 6 amenities
4★ class · 4.5 guest rating · 131 reviews · 5 km from Center
Faraway Nantucket
Peace of Mind65 / 100Some red flags — 4.3★ guest rating; bathroom 45% negative, service 25% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Guest experience: 4.3★ guest rating; bathroom 45% negative, service 25% negative
4★ class · 4.3 guest rating · 376 reviews · 5 km from Center
Blue Iris
Peace of Mind65 / 100Some red flags — 4.2★ guest rating; service 31% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 51 reviews, 5-star, 6 amenities
5★ class · 4.2 guest rating · 51 reviews · 5 km from Center

White Elephant Village
Peace of Mind64 / 100Some red flags — 4.3★ guest rating; service 26% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 50 reviews, 4-star, 3 amenities
4★ class · 4.3 guest rating · 50 reviews · 5 km from Center
Scores blend guest-review sentiment by category, Google location/transit/airport-access ratings, review volume, property class, and amenities. Price context is separate from the score. Hotels with too few reviews are shown without a score rather than guessed.