Finding the best stays in Key West…
Scoring hotels on guest experience, location, and trust — the risks a star rating hides.
Finding the best stays in Key West…
Scoring hotels on guest experience, location, and trust — the risks a star rating hides.
39 hotels rated on the risks stars hide — cleanliness, noise, location, and whether the price is fair for what you get. Our top pick: The Gardens Hotel.
39 scored · Highest Peace of Mind score first. Unscored stays appear last.
Looking for a specific hotel? Search it below — we'll score any property live, even if it's not in our ranked set.

The Gardens Hotel
Peace of Mind86 / 100Few red flags — 4.9★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 762 reviews, 4-star, 10 amenities
4★ class · 4.9 guest rating · 762 reviews · 4 km from Center

The Duval House
Peace of Mind83 / 100Few red flags — 4.7★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 791 reviews, 4-star, 2 amenities
4★ class · 4.7 guest rating · 791 reviews · 4 km from Center
Orchid Key Inn
Peace of Mind83 / 100Few red flags — 4.8★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 440 reviews, 3-star, 10 amenities
3★ class · 4.8 guest rating · 440 reviews · 4 km from Center

The Artist House Bed and Breakfast
Peace of Mind81 / 100Few red flags — 4.8★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 326 reviews, 3-star, 3 amenities
3★ class · 4.8 guest rating · 326 reviews · 4 km from Center
Ocean Key Resort & Spa
Peace of Mind79 / 100Few red flags — 4.6★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 4.2★ location/transit/airport access
4★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 2,456 reviews · 5 km from Center
H2O Suites Hotel
Peace of Mind79 / 100Few red flags — 4.7★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 435 reviews, 5-star, 5 amenities
5★ class · 4.7 guest rating · 435 reviews · 4 km from Center
Santa Maria Suites Resort
Peace of Mind77 / 100Few red flags — 4.7★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 638 reviews, 4-star, 2 amenities
4★ class · 4.7 guest rating · 638 reviews · 4 km from Center
Key West Harbor Inn
Peace of Mind76 / 100Few red flags — 4.8★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 165 reviews, 4-star, 1 amenities
4★ class · 4.8 guest rating · 165 reviews · 4 km from Center
Ella's Cottages - Key West Historic Inns
Peace of Mind76 / 100Few red flags — 4.5★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 458 reviews, 3-star, 7 amenities
3★ class · 4.5 guest rating · 458 reviews · 4 km from Center
Winslow's Bungalows - Key West Historic Inns
Peace of Mind75 / 100Few red flags — 4.4★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 1,299 reviews, 4-star, 10 amenities
4★ class · 4.4 guest rating · 1,299 reviews · 4 km from Center
Silver Palms Inn & Historic Homes
Peace of Mind74 / 100Some red flags — 4.5★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 1,110 reviews, 3-star, 3 amenities
3★ class · 4.5 guest rating · 1,110 reviews · 4 km from Center
Casablanca Hotel Key West
Peace of Mind74 / 100Some red flags — 4.6★ guest rating; sleep 29% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 371 reviews, 3-star, 2 amenities
3★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 371 reviews · 4 km from Center
Eden House Key West
Peace of Mind73 / 100Some red flags — 4.5★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 656 reviews, 3-star, 8 amenities
3★ class · 4.5 guest rating · 656 reviews · 4 km from Center

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa
Peace of Mind73 / 100Some red flags — 4.4★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 4.2★ location/transit/airport access
4★ class · 4.4 guest rating · 1,901 reviews · 5 km from Center

Caribbean House
Peace of Mind71 / 100Some red flags — 4.6★ guest rating; bathroom 39% negative, sleep 24% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 333 reviews, 3-star, 6 amenities
3★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 333 reviews · 4 km from Center
Ridley House - Key West Historic Inns
Peace of Mind71 / 100Some red flags — 4.5★ guest rating; sleep 38% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 469 reviews, 3-star, 8 amenities
3★ class · 4.5 guest rating · 469 reviews · 4 km from Center
Hyatt Vacation Club at Windward Pointe
Peace of Mind70 / 100Some red flags — 4.6★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 3.2★ location/transit/airport access
3★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 1,236 reviews · <1 km from Center
Hyatt Vacation Club at Beach House, Key West
Peace of Mind70 / 100Some red flags — 4.5★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 3.6★ location/transit/airport access
4★ class · 4.5 guest rating · 1,021 reviews · 2 km from Center
Sunset Key Cottages
Peace of Mind69 / 100Some red flags — 4.6★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 2.7★ location/transit/airport access
4★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 946 reviews · 6 km from Center
The Laureate Key West
Peace of Mind67 / 100Some red flags — 4.4★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 3.5★ location/transit/airport access
3★ class · 4.4 guest rating · 1,358 reviews · 2 km from Center

Beachside Resort & Residences
Peace of Mind66 / 100Some red flags — 4.3★ guest rating; service 24% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 3.6★ location/transit/airport access
4★ class · 4.3 guest rating · 3,618 reviews · 2 km from Center
Coconut Beach Resort
Peace of Mind66 / 100Some red flags — 4.5★ guest rating
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 244 reviews, unrated-class, 2 amenities
4.5 guest rating · 244 reviews · 3 km from Center
Westwinds Inn Key West
Peace of Mind66 / 100Some red flags — 4.2★ guest rating; service 21% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Trust: 390 reviews, 4-star, 4 amenities
4★ class · 4.2 guest rating · 390 reviews · 4 km from Center
Parrot Key Hotel & Villas
Peace of Mind65 / 100Some red flags — 4.3★ guest rating; service 25% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Location: 3.7★ location/transit/airport access
4★ class · 4.3 guest rating · 2,481 reviews · 2 km from Center

The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Peace of Mind63 / 100Some red flags — 4.1★ guest rating; service 32% negative, property 21% negative
Lower-scoring factor · Guest experience: 4.1★ guest rating; service 32% negative, property 21% negative
4★ class · 4.1 guest rating · 1,084 reviews · 4 km from Center
Scores blend guest-review sentiment by category, Google location/transit/airport-access ratings, review volume, property class, and amenities. Price context is separate from the score. Hotels with too few reviews are shown without a score rather than guessed.