Finding the best stays in Islip…
Scoring hotels on cleanliness, location, price fairness, and trust — the risks a star rating hides.
Hotels in Islip, United States, scored by risk
51 hotels rated on the risks stars hide — cleanliness, noise, location, and whether the price is fair for what you get. Our top pick: Come As You Are Inn LLC.
Best hotels in Islip · 51 scored, fewest red flags first
Looking for a specific hotel? Search it below — we'll score any property live, even if it's not in our ranked set.
Sort by
Class
Distancefromwithin
Come As You Are Inn LLC
72Some red flags — 5.0★ guest rating
4★ class · 5.0 guest rating · 99 reviews · ~$250/night · 10 km from Center
Oheka Castle
71Some red flags — 4.6★ guest rating
4★ class · 4.6 guest rating · 2,082 reviews · ~$349/night · 22 km from Center
The Ocean Bay House
69Some red flags — 4.9★ guest rating
4★ class · 4.9 guest rating · 96 reviews · ~$480/night · 7 km from Center
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
63Some red flags — 4.4★ guest rating; sleep 36% negative
3★ class · 4.4 guest rating · 581 reviews · ~$151/night · <1 km from Center
The Northport Hotel
63Some red flags — 4.7★ guest rating
4.7 guest rating · 203 reviews · ~$622/night · 20 km from Center
Appalachian Mountain Club Fire Island Cabin
63Some red flags — 4.9★ guest rating
4.9 guest rating · 30 reviews · 14 km from Center
Fire Island Boatel Kismet
63Some red flags — 4.9★ guest rating
4.9 guest rating · 92 reviews · 14 km from Center
Residence Inn by Marriott Melville
63Some red flags — 4.8★ guest rating
3★ class · 4.8 guest rating · 99 reviews · ~$273/night · 19 km from Center
Seashore Condo Hotel
62Some red flags — 4.8★ guest rating
4.8 guest rating · 131 reviews · 13 km from Center
Holiday Inn Long Island - Islip Arpt East by IHG
60Some red flags — 4.4★ guest rating; sleep 23% negative
3★ class · 4.4 guest rating · 781 reviews · ~$122/night · 16 km from Center
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
60Some red flags — 4.3★ guest rating; sleep 40% negative, service 21% negative
3★ class · 4.3 guest rating · 593 reviews · ~$121/night · <1 km from Center
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport
60Some red flags — 4.1★ guest rating
3★ class · 4.1 guest rating · 941 reviews · ~$129/night · 10 km from Center
Dune Point Guest House
59Some red flags — 4.9★ guest rating
3★ class · 4.9 guest rating · 63 reviews · 15 km from Center
Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma
57Some red flags — 4.1★ guest rating; service 29% negative, cleanliness 24% negative
3★ class · 4.1 guest rating · 338 reviews · ~$164/night · 10 km from Center
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville
55Some red flags — 4.1★ guest rating; service 21% negative
3★ class · 4.1 guest rating · 670 reviews · ~$147/night · 13 km from Center
Whitman Motor Lodge
55Some red flags — 4.3★ guest rating; bathroom 33% negative, room 28% negative
2★ class · 4.3 guest rating · 284 reviews · ~$171/night · 19 km from Center
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport
55Some red flags — 3.9★ guest rating
3★ class · 3.9 guest rating · 1,303 reviews · ~$136/night · 7 km from Center
Hollywood Motel
53Several red flags — 3.9★ guest rating; cleanliness 21% negative
4★ class · 3.9 guest rating · 349 reviews · ~$233/night · 19 km from Center
Blue Waters Hotel
52Several red flags — 4.0★ guest rating
4.0 guest rating · 46 reviews · 13 km from Center
Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-Long Island by IHG
51Several red flags — 4.3★ guest rating; bathroom 56% negative
2★ class · 4.3 guest rating · 853 reviews · ~$160/night · 16 km from Center
Best Western Bar Harbour Inn
51Several red flags — 3.7★ guest rating; service 26% negative
3★ class · 3.7 guest rating · 885 reviews · ~$126/night · 23 km from Center
Jake's 58 Casino Hotel
50Several red flags — 3.8★ guest rating; service 32% negative, property 25% negative
3★ class · 3.8 guest rating · 6,090 reviews · ~$100/night · 6 km from Center
Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island
49Several red flags — 4.0★ guest rating; room 58% negative
4★ class · 4.0 guest rating · 617 reviews · ~$105/night · 18 km from Center
Chalet Inn & Suites
49Several red flags — 3.9★ guest rating
2★ class · 3.9 guest rating · 219 reviews · ~$149/night · 20 km from Center
Best Western Premier Plainview-Long Island Hotel
49Several red flags — 3.5★ guest rating
3★ class · 3.5 guest rating · 46 reviews · ~$152/night · 21 km from Center